How the money is supposed to flow
Stop-loss is the reason a mid-size employer can self-fund at all. It has two parts, and both depend on accumulators: running totals the stop-loss carrier keeps and almost nobody else recomputes.
- Specific caps what the plan pays for any one person. Above the specific deductible ($50,000 in this example), the stop-loss carrier reimburses the excess.
- Aggregate caps what the plan pays in total. The attachment point is a monthly factor times enrolled employees. Claims above it are reimbursed, and on a level-funded plan, claims below it leave a surplus that's partly refunded.
- The contract basis says which claims count. On a 12/15 contract, a claim counts if it was incurred during the 12-month plan year and paid within 15 months, so the plan year plus a three-month runout.
Our sample group, Harbor Point Manufacturing, is level-funded with Meridian. The Medical PPO rates on its list bill aren't premiums in the insured sense. Each one is four amounts added together:
| Tier | Admin | Specific | Aggregate | Claims fund | Monthly rate |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| EE | $46.50 | $58.20 | $7.85 | $207.54 | $320.09 |
| EE+SP | $46.50 | $125.10 | $16.90 | $499.09 | $687.59 |
| EE+CH | $46.50 | $110.60 | $14.95 | $436.12 | $608.17 |
| FAM | $46.50 | $157.30 | $21.25 | $639.56 | $864.61 |
So the stop-loss premium is already covered by the bill audit: if the tier is wrong, the stop-loss premium inside it is wrong too. If your stop-loss is bought separately and billed on its own invoice, the same per-employee check runs on that bill. This page is about the other direction, the money stop-loss owes the plan.
One person, two IDs
Michael Grimaldi had a bad year: a hospitalization in November, follow-up care through June. In March, Meridian reissued his member ID after an SSN correction on the eligibility file. The claim system handled that fine. The specific accumulator is keyed by member ID, so it treated him as two people:
| Carrier ID | Service dates | Claims | Accumulated |
|---|---|---|---|
| MRD5850075 | Oct 6 → Feb 9 | 5 | $41,860.00 |
| MRD3589425 | Mar 11 → Jun 3 | 3 | $27,145.30 |
| One person | 8 | $69,005.30 | |
| Less specific deductible | −$50,000.00 | ||
| Reimbursement due | $19,005.30 | ||
| Reimbursement credited | $0.00 | ||
| Owed to the plan | $19,005.30 | ||
Meridian's own large-claimant report lists him twice, both times below the deductible. Nobody reads that report looking for duplicates, because each line is believable.
The runout that got cut off
Brenda Kowalczyk crossed the deductible in May. Meridian credited a reimbursement of $13,480.00 on $63,480.00 of claims: correct for everything paid by August 31. The contract is 12/15, though, and two of her claims were incurred in August but paid in the runout:
| Claim | Incurred | Paid | 12/12 (applied) | 12/15 (contract) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Claims paid by August 31 | $63,480.00 | $63,480.00 | ||
| CLM40001398 | Aug 12 | Sep 10 | excluded | $8,734.20 |
| CLM40001483 | Aug 26 | Oct 2 | excluded | $3,191.40 |
| Paid toward specific | $63,480.00 | $75,405.60 | ||
| Reimbursement | $13,480.00 | $25,405.60 | ||
| Owed to the plan | $11,925.60 | |||
She was already past the deductible, so every runout dollar is reimbursable. The accumulator was simply configured with the wrong basis, and it will do the same for every claimant whose care runs into the last month of the plan year.
The one that's right
Steven Lockhart: $58,210.00 paid in basis, $8,210.00 credited. Correct to the penny. We show it because recomputing every accumulator is what makes the two errors above provable. "Lockhart ties out, Grimaldi and Kowalczyk don't" is a much stronger letter to a stop-loss carrier than "we think something's off."
The aggregate inherits everything
The aggregate accumulator is where every other error ends up. Ineligible claims (see claims after termination) count as plan claims. Specific excess that was never credited stays in plan claims instead of being removed. Here's Meridian's preliminary aggregate next to the recomputed one:
| Line | Carrier | Recomputed |
|---|---|---|
| Aggregate attachment | $915,908.65 | $915,908.65 |
| Claims paid in basis | $741,610.34 | $731,769.29 |
| Less specific excess | −$21,690.00 | −$52,620.90 |
| Net aggregate claims | $719,920.34 | $679,148.39 |
| Surplus | $195,988.31 | $236,760.26 |
The difference is $40,771.95, exactly the $9,841.05 of ineligible claims plus the $30,930.90 of uncredited specific excess. That tie-out is the point: the aggregate isn't a seventh error. It's the check that the settlement will reflect the other six once they're credited. At this contract's 50% surplus share, it's $20,385.98 more refund to Harbor Point at settlement.
Why nobody catches it
The TPA files specific claims from the stop-loss carrier's accumulator. The broker gets a settlement statement with totals. The employer sees one number at the end of the runout. Everyone trusts the accumulator, and nobody recomputes it person by person on the contract basis, because doing that means joining a year of claims to eligibility and the policy schedule. That join is the work we do.